A redesigned plan for storage condos on South Samson Trail would still not be compatible with surrounding homes, the McCall Area Planning and Zoning Commission said on Tuesday.The application by Carmello Echanis of Boise calls for three buildings containing 38 storage condos to be built on 2.8 acres at 450 South Samson Trail, or near Krahn Lane.The P&Z, however, will recommend denial of the proposal amid worries that traffic from the storage condos and the commercial aesthetic would harm nearby homes.“I don’t believe this is the right fit,” commissioner Dana Paugh said.The application will now advance to the Valley County Commission for a final decision after a public hearing, for which no date has been set.Tuesday’s recommendation to deny the application was the second time Echanis’ storage condo application was opposed by the P&Z.In December, the P&Z recommended denial of a previous version of the application that called for two additional buildings that would have industrial tenants.Current plans were scaled back from the December application that was rejected to reduce worries about traffic raised by commissioners.Three people spoke in opposition to the proposal at Tuesday’s public hearing, each of whom said the storage condos would conflict with South Samson Trail’s designation as a scenic route by the City of McCall.“This thing is just going to be an eye sore along that corridor,” said Kim Apperson, who lives near the proposal on South Samson Trail.Development applications along designated scenic routes are subject to stricter review and design standards to preserve visual aesthetics.Valley County has final say over the project because it is within the McCall Impact Area, which is county land that surrounds city limits and is governed by zoning laws that mirror those in place in the city.The site proposed for the industrial storage complex is zoned as community commercial, which means a conditional use permit is required to build the facility.Conditional use permit applications are subject to a 12-point evaluation by the P&Z to assess compatibility with surrounding properties.All 12 criteria must be met for the permit to be approved.